Payton May
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2020
Payton May
London Hibbs
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2019
London Hibbs
Jessica Baedar
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2018
Jessica Baedar
Nicole Jia
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2017
Nicole Jia
Allie Nault
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2016
Allie Nault
Olivia McMillan
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2015
Olivia McMillan
Leah Sykes
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2014
Leah Sykes
Rachel Wyatt
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2013
Rachel Wyatt
Elizabeth Fechtel
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2012
Elizabeth Fechtel
Lacey Russ
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2011
Lacey Russ
Jeanette Morelan
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2010
Jeanette Morelan
Taylor Fitch
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2009
Taylor Fitch
Caitlin Brunell
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2008
Caitlin Brunell
Maria DeSantis
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2007
Maria DeSantis
Meghan Miller
Miss America’s
Outstanding Teen 2006
Meghan Miller